Und die ihr alle meine Brüder seid by Ida Frohnmeyer

(2 User reviews)   460
Frohnmeyer, Ida, 1882-1968 Frohnmeyer, Ida, 1882-1968
German
Hey, I just finished this book that's been sitting on my shelf forever, and wow—it really got under my skin. It's called 'Und die ihr alle meine Brüder seid' by Ida Frohnmeyer, and it's not your typical historical novel. Forget grand battle scenes; this one is quiet, personal, and surprisingly tense. It follows a German family—parents and their adult son—right after World War I. The war is over, but nothing feels settled. Their son, Martin, comes home changed, carrying wounds you can't see. The real conflict isn't on a battlefield; it's in their cramped apartment. It's in the silences at the dinner table, the things left unsaid, and the slow, painful process of trying to be a family again when the world you knew has vanished. The mystery isn't about a crime, but about whether these people can ever truly find each other again. It's a small story with a huge emotional punch.
Share

Ida Frohnmeyer's novel, written in the 1920s but feeling incredibly fresh, zooms in on the aftermath of the Great War through the eyes of one ordinary Berlin family. The fighting has stopped, but the real work—the work of picking up the pieces—is just beginning.

The Story

We meet the Hoffmanns: Friedrich, a weary clerk; his wife, Elsa, who has held everything together; and their son, Martin, who returns from the front a stranger. The plot is deceptively simple. It's about Martin trying to find a job in a broken economy, his parents tiptoeing around his moods, and the three of them navigating a new, awkward domesticity. The tension comes from what's not said. A slammed door, a half-finished sentence, a memory that flashes across Martin's face—these are the building blocks of the story. The war is a ghost in every room, affecting everything from their finances to how they pour a cup of coffee.

Why You Should Read It

What grabbed me was how real it all felt. Frohnmeyer doesn't give us heroes or villains, just deeply human people who are exhausted, grieving, and trying their best. Elsa's quiet desperation to 'fix' her son is heartbreaking. Martin's anger and isolation are palpable. You keep reading not for a big twist, but to see if this fragile family unit can bend without breaking. It's a powerful look at trauma, not with today's clinical language, but with the raw, confused understanding of the time. It makes you think about all the quiet, private wars that continue long after the treaties are signed.

Final Verdict

This book is perfect for readers who love character-driven stories and nuanced historical fiction. If you enjoyed the intimate family portraits in novels like All Quiet on the Western Front but wanted to see what happened after the soldier came home, this is your next read. It's not a fast-paced adventure; it's a slow, thoughtful, and ultimately moving look at resilience. A forgotten gem that deserves to be found again.



✅ Usage Rights

This historical work is free of copyright protections. Thank you for supporting open literature.

Margaret Walker
1 year ago

I stumbled upon this title and the narrative structure is incredibly compelling. Definitely a 5-star read.

Michelle Wright
1 year ago

After finishing this book, the storytelling feels authentic and emotionally grounded. A true masterpiece.

4.5
4.5 out of 5 (2 User reviews )

Add a Review

Your Rating *
There are no comments for this eBook.
You must log in to post a comment.
Log in

Related eBooks